
Say it isn't so, Moe..say it isn't so.
Both Variety and the Independent Film Guide report this morning that MGM has given the green light to a new Three Stooges feature film, set to start shooting in September of this year.
But this isn't a biopic..it's intended to be a feature length comedy featuring the characters of Moe, Larry and Curly. The Farrelly Brothers, who once upon a time actually made GOOD movies (
Dumb and Dumber, Kingpin, There's Something About Mary) but have lately been responsible for such duds as
Fever Pitch and
The Heartbreak Kid, are set to write and direct.
The casting will really have you scratching your head. Jim Carrey will play Curly Howard. I suppose it couldwork (I doubt it, though) , but Sean Penn as Larry Fine? Benicio Del Toro as Moe Howard? Can I get a collective
HUH? here? All three are fine actors, but Moe Howard, Larry Fine and Curly Howard (and let's include Shemp Howard in this too) are AMERICAN ORIGINALS. I'm hesitant to use the label genius, but they were indeed comic geniuses. Who else made lowbrow comedy so deliciously highbrow and with such skill and flair? The trio are IRREPLACEABLE. And are Penn and Del Toro renowned for comedic skill?
Besides, remember these bursts of remake creativity from Hollywood...

Whoever thought Cedric the Entertainer and Mike Epps were perfect replacements for Jackie Gleason and Art Carney can no longer read this blog.

Whoever thought Bronson Pinchot would be an adequate replacement for Stan Laurel deserves to be shot.